Score breakdown

Sparks of Artificial General Intelligence: Early Experiments with GPT-4

paper-0153 · paper · 2023

Sebastien Bubeck et al.

The most-debated capability claim of the era; framed the AGI-proximity argument.

Academic, score -0.2072

MetricStatusValueNorm.WeightContributionSourceConfidenceProvenance
citation_countpresent1552.00.0069820.50.003491OpenAlexhighlink
library_holdingsmissingrecorded as missing, penalized by rule, never imputed−0.1recorded as missing; penalized by rule, never imputed
readership_persistencepresent5.00.2857140.050.014286OpenAlexmediumlink
syllabus_adoptionsmissingrecorded as missing, penalized by rule, never imputed−0.125recorded as missing; penalized by rule, never imputed

Broad Influence, score -0.0843

MetricStatusValueNorm.WeightContributionSourceConfidenceProvenance
citation_countpresent1552.00.0069820.20.001396OpenAlexhighlink
library_holdingsmissingrecorded as missing, penalized by rule, never imputed−0.125recorded as missing; penalized by rule, never imputed
readership_persistencepresent5.00.2857140.40.114286OpenAlexmediumlink
syllabus_adoptionsmissingrecorded as missing, penalized by rule, never imputed−0.075recorded as missing; penalized by rule, never imputed

Governance Practitioner, score -0.2947

MetricStatusValueNorm.WeightContributionSourceConfidenceProvenance
citation_countpresent1552.00.0069820.250.001745OpenAlexhighlink
library_holdingsmissingrecorded as missing, penalized by rule, never imputed−0.15recorded as missing; penalized by rule, never imputed
readership_persistencepresent5.00.2857140.10.028571OpenAlexmediumlink
syllabus_adoptionsmissingrecorded as missing, penalized by rule, never imputed−0.175recorded as missing; penalized by rule, never imputed

A rank is not a verdict on intrinsic worth. It is a transparent output of declared evidence, weights, and missing-data rules at a specific release date.

Disagree with this rank or a number? Challenge it with your evidence. Every challenge gets a public identifier and a published resolution.